Today, let’s take a look at interesting facts about Scandium and answer the following questions: “Why Is Scandium Considered A Rare Earth Element?”, and “Why Is Scandium Considered A Critical Raw Material?”

Why Is Scandium Considered A Rare Earth Element?

Scandium is considered a rare earth element primarily due to its chemical similarities to the lanthanides, despite having significant differences in its geological occurrence and atomic properties. Scandium (atomic number 21) is chemically similar to the lanthanides and yttrium, which justifies its occasional inclusion in the rare earth element group. The element shares the characteristic 3+ oxidation state common to all rare earth elements and exhibits similar chemical behavior in many compounds. However, scandium has a smaller ionic radius than yttrium and the lanthanides, with its chemical behavior described as “intermediate between that of aluminum and the lanthanides.” This intermediate nature reflects scandium’s position in the periodic table as the first d-block element in period 4.

The classification of scandium as a rare earth element is more tenuous than that of yttrium, and many authorities treat it separately. While scandium is found in nature with the lanthanides and yttrium to some degree, it “does not commonly occur in significant quantities in the same mineral deposits with the lanthanides and yttrium.” This geological separation distinguishes scandium from the other rare earth elements, which typically occur together in deposits. The difference is so pronounced that scandium is often excluded from rare earth element discussions, with one source explicitly stating scandium “will not be discussed further” after noting its chemical similarities.

The practical considerations for scandium’s classification reveal why its status as a rare earth element remains debated. Unlike the lanthanides and yttrium, which concentrate together in minerals like bastnäsite, monazite, and xenotime, scandium tends to be dispersed in various minerals without forming concentrated deposits. Its smaller atomic size (atomic number 21) and ionic radius mean it doesn’t substitute as readily for the larger rare earth elements in crystal structures. When scandium does occur in rare earth deposits, it is typically in “minor amounts because of its smaller atomic and ionic size.” This sporadic occurrence pattern makes scandium economically different from the other rare earth elements.

From an industrial and economic perspective, scandium’s inclusion with the rare earth elements is inconsistent. While global scandium consumption was estimated at only 15 to 25 tons per year, its primary uses in aluminum-scandium alloys and fuel cells are distinct from typical rare earth applications. Major scandium production comes from different sources than traditional rare earth mining – for example, the Sumitomo Metal Mining operation in the Philippines recovers scandium as a byproduct from nickel laterite processing, targeting up to 7.5 tons per year of scandium oxide equivalent. This separate production stream, combined with scandium’s absence from major rare earth deposits like Mountain Pass or Bayan Obo, reinforces its distinct position. While scandium shares enough chemical properties to be grouped with the rare earth elements in some classification systems, its unique geological occurrence, smaller ionic size, and separate production pathways make it more of an honorary member of the rare earth element family rather than a true member like yttrium.

Why Is Scandium Considered A Critical Raw Material?

Scandium is considered a critical raw material due to its combination of extremely limited global supply, highly specialized applications, and severe supply concentration. Global scandium consumption is remarkably small at only 15 to 25 metric tons per year, reflecting both its scarcity and the challenges in obtaining it. Unlike other rare earth elements that occur in concentrated deposits, scandium “does not commonly occur in significant quantities in the same mineral deposits with the lanthanides and yttrium,” instead being dispersed across various minerals without forming economically viable primary deposits. This dispersed occurrence means scandium must typically be recovered as a byproduct from other mining operations, such as from nickel laterite processing in the Philippines where Sumitomo Metal Mining targets production of up to 7.5 metric tons per year of scandium oxide equivalent.

The criticality of scandium stems from its unique and irreplaceable properties in high-technology applications, particularly in aerospace and clean energy sectors. Scandium’s primary uses include aluminum-scandium alloys, which provide exceptional strength-to-weight ratios crucial for aerospace applications, and solid oxide fuel cells for clean energy generation. The metal’s importance in defense applications is evidenced by its inclusion in the U.S. Department of Defense’s strategic planning, with the fiscal year 2024 National Defense Stockpile including potential acquisitions of scandium. Several advanced rare earth projects specifically identify scandium as a target commodity, including NioCorp’s Elk Creek project in Nebraska, Rare Element Resources’ Bear Lodge project in Wyoming, and various Australian projects, indicating growing recognition of its strategic importance.

The supply vulnerability of scandium is acute due to the absence of primary scandium mines and dependence on limited byproduct recovery operations. Current production comes from scattered sources recovering scandium as a byproduct, with China and Russia being major producers. The Philippines operation by Sumitomo represents one of the few documented commercial-scale scandium recovery facilities outside of China and Russia. This extreme supply concentration, combined with the lack of established primary deposits, creates significant risk for industries dependent on scandium. The Resnick Institute and other expert panels have highlighted scandium among critical materials for emerging technologies, particularly for lightweight alloys and clean energy applications.

The economic and strategic challenges surrounding scandium are exemplified by the contrast between its potential and actual use. Despite its valuable properties, scandium applications remain limited by its high cost and restricted availability – a self-reinforcing cycle where limited supply keeps prices high (reaching $700-1,700 per kilogram for some rare earth oxides), which in turn limits demand and discourages investment in new production capacity. Australian resources reports identify significant scandium reserves of 27,000 metric tons with economic demonstrated resources of 13,000 metric tons, suggesting that resources exist but remain largely undeveloped. The combination of scandium’s unique properties in lightweight alloys and clean energy technologies, its extremely limited and concentrated production, the absence of primary mines, and its inclusion in defense stockpile considerations firmly establishes scandium as a critical raw material for advanced economies.

Interesting Facts About Scandium

1. Scandium is the first transition metal in the periodic table, marking the beginning of the d-block elements with atomic number 21.
2. Despite being classified as a rare earth element, scandium is actually more abundant in Earth’s crust than lead, mercury, or silver – it’s just extremely dispersed and rarely forms concentrated deposits.
3. Scandium has an unusually low density for a transition metal (2.985 g/cm³), making it the second lightest transition metal after titanium.
4. When added to aluminum alloys in tiny amounts (0.1-0.5%), scandium dramatically increases strength and weldability while reducing grain size, creating aerospace-grade materials.
5. Scandium oxide (Sc₂O₃) has one of the highest melting points of all rare earth oxides at 2,489°C (4,512°F).
6. Pure scandium metal develops a yellowish or pinkish cast when exposed to air, unlike most metals that form gray or white oxide layers.
7. Scandium has only one stable isotope (⁴⁵Sc), making it one of 26 monoisotopic elements – unusual for elements with odd atomic numbers.
8. The element exhibits an anomalously high electronegativity (1.36) compared to other Group 3 elements, approaching values typical of later transition metals.
9. Scandium iodide is used in metal halide lamps to produce light closely resembling natural sunlight, with a color rendering index near 100.
10. Unlike other rare earth elements, scandium doesn’t form stable carbides under normal conditions, setting it apart chemically from its lanthanide cousins.
11. Scandium has an unusually small ionic radius for its position in the periodic table, causing it to behave more like aluminum than other rare earth elements in many compounds.
12. The element was predicted by Mendeleev in 1869 as “ekaboron” with remarkably accurate property predictions, 10 years before its actual discovery.
13. Scandium-46 is used as a radioactive tracer in oil refining to track crude oil movement through crackers and pipelines due to its ideal 84-day half-life.
14. Pure scandium metal is remarkably soft (similar to aluminum) but becomes extremely hard when alloyed, showing one of the largest hardness increases of any alloying element.
15. Scandium trifluoride (ScF₃) exhibits negative thermal expansion – it contracts when heated – a rare property useful for creating zero-expansion composites.
16. The element forms unusually stable complexes with organic ligands compared to other early transition metals, making it useful in catalysis.
17. Scandium has the highest charge-to-radius ratio of any +3 ion, giving it exceptional Lewis acid properties in chemical reactions.
18. Nuclear magnetic resonance of ⁴⁵Sc provides one of the widest chemical shift ranges of any nucleus, making it exceptionally sensitive for NMR spectroscopy.
19. Scandium’s first ionization energy (633.1 kJ/mol) is anomalously high for a Group 3 element, exceeding that of aluminum and approaching zinc’s value.
20. The element preferentially substitutes for magnesium rather than aluminum in minerals despite similar ionic sizes, due to its unique electronic configuration and bonding preferences.

Thanks for reading!