Today, let’s take a look at interesting facts about Lutetium and answer the following questions: “Why Is Lutetium Considered A Rare Earth Element?”, and “Why Is Lutetium Considered A Critical Raw Material?”

For more information, check out the light rare earth elements (LREEs) as a group, the heavy rare earth elements (HREEs) as a group, and all rare earth elements (REEs). Be sure to check out all other critical raw materials (CRMs), as well.

Why Is Lutetium Considered A Rare Earth Element?

Lutetium is considered a rare earth element because it is the final member of the 15 lanthanide elements that constitute the core group of rare earth elements. With atomic number 71, lutetium represents the end of the lanthanide series that begins with lanthanum (atomic number 57). As stated in the documents, “The REE group is composed of 15 elements that range in atomic number from 57 (lanthanum) to 71 (lutetium).” As the last lanthanide, lutetium exhibits all the characteristic chemical properties that define this group, including the typical trivalent oxidation state (Lu3+) and the smallest ionic radius among the lanthanides due to maximum lanthanide contraction. This systematic decrease in ionic radius from lanthanum to lutetium is a defining characteristic of the lanthanide series.

Lutetium’s classification as a heavy rare earth element reflects both its position at the end of the lanthanide series and its geochemical behavior. The heavy rare earth elements “comprise terbium through lutetium (atomic numbers 65 through 71),” with lutetium representing the heaviest member of this subgroup. With a crustal abundance of only 0.8 parts per million, lutetium is one of the two least abundant rare earth elements alongside thulium. Despite this scarcity, lutetium is still “nearly 200 times more common than gold,” illustrating that the term “rare” earth elements is a historical misnomer based on the difficulty of separating these elements rather than their actual crustal abundance. In rare earth deposits, lutetium typically occurs in the lowest concentrations of any REE – at Mountain Pass, the combined content of all heavy REEs from europium through lutetium plus yttrium totals only 0.4% of the rare earth oxides.

Lutetium’s geochemical behavior exemplifies the fundamental characteristics of rare earth elements. Like all REEs, lutetium has a high charge (+3) and, despite having the smallest ionic radius among the lanthanides, still cannot readily substitute into common rock-forming minerals. This incompatibility causes lutetium to concentrate with other rare earth elements during magmatic processes until specialized REE minerals crystallize. Lutetium invariably occurs with other rare earth elements in nature, particularly in minerals that can accommodate heavy rare earth elements such as xenotime ((Y,HREE,Th,U)PO4), where it can substitute for yttrium and other heavy lanthanides. The principle that “REEs can substitute for one another in crystal structures, and multiple REEs typically occur within a single mineral” applies to lutetium, which never occurs in isolation.

From scientific and industrial perspectives, lutetium perfectly exemplifies the rare earth element group while highlighting the extreme end of the series. The observation that “for many years the main use of lutetium was the study of the behavior of lutetium” encapsulates how the scarcity and high cost of the heavy rare earth elements limited their applications. Despite its rarity, lutetium has found specialized uses that leverage its rare earth properties, including applications in petroleum refining and specialized optical materials. As noted, “lutetium is used in immersion lithography, which requires a high-refractive index,” demonstrating how its unique electronic properties as a lanthanide enable specific technological applications. 

The combination of lutetium’s position as the final lanthanide, its characteristic REE chemistry including the Lu3+ oxidation state and systematic ionic radius, its consistent co-occurrence with other REEs in minerals, and its specialized applications establishes lutetium as the culminating member of the rare earth element series.

Why Is Lutetium Considered A Critical Raw Material?

Lutetium is considered a critical raw material due to its extreme scarcity, specialized high-technology applications with no substitutes, and complete dependence on Chinese supply chains. As one of the two least abundant rare earth elements with a crustal abundance of only 0.8 parts per million, lutetium represents the extreme end of rare earth scarcity. In major rare earth deposits, lutetium concentrations are vanishingly small – at Mountain Pass, California, the combined content of all heavy rare earth elements from europium through lutetium plus yttrium totals only 0.4% of the rare earth oxides, with lutetium comprising the smallest fraction. This extreme scarcity means lutetium can only be produced as a byproduct of processing enormous quantities of other rare earth elements, making its availability entirely dependent on the economics of large-scale rare earth mining.

The criticality of lutetium is severely amplified by the absolute concentration of heavy rare earth element production and processing in China. Between 2011 and 2017, China produced approximately 84% of the world’s rare earth elements, but more critically, China’s ion-adsorption clay deposits are “the world’s primary source of the heavy REEs.” These deposits in southern China represent the only economically viable source of lutetium because they are enriched in heavy rare earth elements and “the REEs can be easily extracted from the clays with weak acids.” When China announced export restrictions in 2010 through quotas, licenses, and taxes, it created extreme vulnerability for lutetium supply. The processing infrastructure presents an additional bottleneck – “nearly all REE separation and refining” occurs within China, meaning even rare earth ores mined elsewhere must be sent to China for the complex process of separating lutetium from other lanthanides.

Lutetium’s strategic importance lies in its irreplaceable applications in petroleum refining and advanced optical technologies. The element is specifically used in petroleum refining catalysts where its unique chemical properties enable critical processes in fuel production. In optical applications, “lutetium is used in immersion lithography, which requires a high-refractive index,” a technology essential for manufacturing advanced semiconductor chips. These applications have no adequate substitutes because they depend on lutetium’s specific electronic and optical properties as the heaviest lanthanide. The statement that “for many years the main use of lutetium was the study of the behavior of lutetium” reflects how extreme scarcity and cost have constrained applications, suggesting significant unmet demand.

The economic dynamics of lutetium exemplify the self-reinforcing cycle that makes it critically vulnerable. Current prices of “many thousand dollars per kilogram” limit applications to only the most essential uses where no substitutes exist. The observation that if prices “were to decrease from many thousand to a few thousand dollars per kilogram… additional high-technology applications of even this least abundant of the REE undoubtedly would follow” indicates substantial latent demand constrained by supply. Expert panels from the National Research Council, U.S. Department of Energy, and European Commission have ranked rare earth elements as having the highest “criticality” ratings, with lutetium representing the extreme case – combining maximum scarcity with irreplaceable applications. 

The convergence of lutetium’s status as the least abundant lanthanide, its essential role in petroleum refining and semiconductor manufacturing, the complete concentration of viable deposits and separation facilities in China, and the absence of any substitute materials establishes lutetium as one of the most critical raw materials, where supply disruptions could eliminate entire industrial processes with no alternatives available.

Interesting Facts About Lutetium

1. Lutetium is the last element in the lanthanide series and has the highest atomic number (71) of all rare earth elements, making it the hardest and densest of the lanthanides.
2. It has the smallest atomic radius among the lanthanides due to “lanthanide contraction” – a phenomenon where atomic radii decrease across the series despite increasing atomic number.
3. Lutetium has an unusually high melting point (1663°C) compared to other rare earth elements, making it valuable for high-temperature applications.
4. Unlike most other lanthanides which have unpaired 4f electrons, lutetium has a completely filled 4f electron shell ([Xe]4f¹⁴5d¹6s²), giving it unique chemical properties.
5. It’s the least abundant of all naturally occurring rare earth elements, with only 0.5 parts per million in Earth’s crust – about 200 times rarer than cerium.
6. Lutetium-177 is a medically important radioisotope used in targeted radiotherapy for neuroendocrine tumors and prostate cancer, with a half-life of 6.6 days.
7. Natural lutetium contains about 2.6% of the radioactive isotope lutetium-176, which has an extraordinarily long half-life of 37.8 billion years and is used for geological dating.
8. Lutetium has the highest Vickers hardness (about 1160 MPa) among all rare earth metals, making it exceptionally resistant to mechanical deformation.
9. It exhibits unusual magnetic properties – it’s paramagnetic at room temperature but becomes ferromagnetic at extremely low temperatures below 0.1 K.
10. Lutetium aluminum garnet (LuAG) has one of the highest densities among oxide scintillators and is used in medical imaging and high-energy physics detectors.
11. The element has an exceptionally high thermal neutron capture cross-section (2,100 barns), making it useful as a burnable nuclear poison in nuclear reactors.
12. Lutetium was the last naturally occurring rare earth element to be discovered (1907) and was independently isolated by three different scientists who gave it different names.
13. It’s the only lanthanide that commonly exhibits a +3 oxidation state exclusively in all its compounds, with no stable +2 or +4 states.
14. Lutetium metal is one of the most expensive naturally occurring elements, costing approximately $10,000 per kilogram due to difficult separation processes.
15. The element has the highest electronegativity (1.27 on the Pauling scale) among all lanthanides, approaching the values of transition metals.
16. Lutetium compounds show minimal f-f electronic transitions, resulting in colorless or white compounds unlike the colored compounds of other lanthanides.
17. It has the smallest ionic radius among trivalent lanthanide ions (Lu³⁺), leading to the strongest metal-ligand bonds in coordination compounds.
18. Lutetium-based catalysts show unique selectivity in petroleum cracking processes due to their strong Lewis acidity and small ionic size.
19. The element’s extremely low magnetic moment (0.0 Bohr magnetons) makes it ideal for studying crystal field effects without magnetic interference.
20. Lutetium hafnium oxide has one of the highest dielectric constants (k~25) among binary oxides, making it a promising gate dielectric material for advanced transistors.

Thanks for reading!